Anonymous. I haven't asked any questions for a while now, and this is a serious question. I'd rather be in the woods with a guy who knows his limitations than with some of the yahoos that buy the biggest caliber they can find and blast everything to smithereens. [ARCHIVED THREAD] - Deer Kill with .22 Short. I have a couple easy hosting options. I have a resigned Farrell R Collett and numbered 4/10Â 1980 print of a mule deer for the Ruffed Grouse Society. The brain is a vital organ, and a well-placed shot to a deer’s brain will disrupt all its … There are plenty of deer in low state SC and in years past, I have found dead ones that were hit with multilple shotgun pellets and ran off to die anyway. It seems plenty powerful enough to do it, so since its quiet can I use it to hunt deer quietly without anyone hearing? But, it doesn't leave a lot of wiggle room. You clearly have a antisocial mental disorder as well as a narcissistic personality. Some spots a .22 short may penetrate, some it may not, some it may be deflected off. Sure, a .22 will kill alot of things if shot placement is spot on. From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm. A true sportsman tries to prevent suffering of the animal so uses a round that can kill quickly. This is a new rifle for the 2019 Remington lineup. Pass sniper school in the marines you might be that good a shot. What do YOU want to see on ARFCOM's Youtube channel in 2021? I can not, for the life of me, figure out why a guy would want to go out and "hunt" deer with a 5.5" barreled pistol with .22 shorts. AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own. Good judgement comes from bad experience; most of that comes from bad judgement. The hunter was sure he had hit the deer as it reacted like it had been struck. 9 years ago. He had an opportunity and took it. .22 shorts are plenty powerful enough for squirrels. The .22 Short is only for very small game, not deer or bear. I swear that if I kill a deer between now and the 25th, I am going to butcher it in the front yard and try to make jerky over a fire. No. In fact, my grandfather killed his first deer with a Winchester Model 43 in.22 Hornet many years ago. Maybe. It has also become almost the standard long range deer and antelope cartridge for beginning hunters. Can you help me. Many states require a 30 caliber or higher for deer. I'd never try that. Kicked out of Capitol, Trump diehards vow to fight on, Why attack on U.S. Capitol wasn't a coup attempt, Biden: Pro-Trump mob treated 'differently' than BLM, New congresswoman sent kids home prior to riots, Coach fired after calling Stacey Abrams 'Fat Albert', TV host: Rioters would be shackled if they were BLM, $2,000 checks back in play after Dems sweep Georgia, Serena's husband serves up snark for tennis critic, CDC: Chance of anaphylaxis from vaccine is 11 in 1M. The resultant shock paralyzes the deer nervous system grounding it on the spot. His range was short, under one hundred yards. He shot it. I honestly would have said it wouldn't work. Out of season insinuates poaching,,a crime. (If I get desperate, I may shoot one in the front yard). It is illegal to hunt deer in New Hampshire with a .22. My feelings are if you only have one rifle and it is a 22-250 go ahead and use … These are the same questions that every hunter should be asking, no matter what the game or caliber being used is. will cycle through almost any short action rifle, whether bolt, lever, pump, or semi-auto. My favorite lever gun for deer for a long time was a Marlin 1895 with a 22-inch barrel in.45-70 Government. GOP delegate films himself breaking into Capitol. The .22 Hornet is intended for varmints, small game, and predators. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. You can sign in to vote the answer. All Rights Reserved. Karma will nail you trolls one day bank on it. Now first let me say that I could not give a crap how you put meat on the plate but how is this not poaching? Holding a gun has nothing to do with being able to kill a deer with a .22 cal bullet. They are by far my favorite round for hunting, but the CCI sub-sonic hollow point long rifles are just as good and a little quieter. Absolutely. I knew an old gold miner in the great state of Oregon who lived off the land on his claim for many months out of each year. Good shooting and a good test of survival skills. 0 0. And I've heard of a case of a man trying to drive off an elephant with a .22, he wasn't careful about shot placement and hit the ear canal...ended up in jail. While the item may be priced similarly at different shops. Remember, that when hunting with an … But why would you take on such a risky endeavour like that unless you had too. If the deer survives after the shot it will likely suffer a while. The deer took off for parts unknown and that was the last time it was seen. A good shot at this part disable the deer front limbs immobilizing it so it does not run away. The absolute minimum caliber I would use on a deer … Whether you shoot a .30-06 or a .375 H&H Mag, if you don’t hit vital organs, you won’t consistently or reliably kill deer. I'm impressed. .22 Savage Hi-Power While the Winchester Model 1894 was the rifle of the deer hunting masses, the Savage Model 99 was the thinking hunter’s rifle. Who was the man seen in fur storming U.S. Capitol? Let me sart out by saying I'm glad it worked out for you. Yes it is advisable when hunting in a subdivision. Some people are want to buy 22 Rifle Kill Deer And 22 Rifle With Scope Near 54923 with the cheap price. "The first rule of a gun fight, of course, is to have a gun" -Ted Nugent. I know you can kill deer with a 22-250, I have killed them with 22 long rifles and 22 mag. It’s the gun that “gun guys” gravitated to when the fall turned cold and the bucks were rutting. A sub is essentially a broadhead, if you are smart enough to choose one of the few bullets that can expand at such velocities (IMHO a broadhead is better). But I believe if you keep it up you're going to end up making a mess one day. If guns kill people, do pencils misspell words? Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more. AR15.COM is the world’s largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. What matter more with guns quality or qualityÂ ? Just a fancy .22 … And NO a .22 short will only wound a deer that far away. [Last Edit: 12/5/2008 3:22:49 AM EST by buckfever34]. Around here that would be poaching for sure. Optics 1 ECOTI Latest Fusion Available Commercially Exclusively Through TNVC NOW SHIPPING! I would call them a bad shot and I would still call your choice unethical and the state of South Carolina's decision to allow rimfire to be used on deer a poor one. Sometimes the answers will change by the moment also. BC ? A deer standing broadside to the shooter gives the hunter a straight shot to the animal’s exposed vitals, giving the best chance at a clean kill and easy recovery. In a survival situation, you do what you have to do, but I didn't get the vibe that's what it was. Not in most places. Shooting large game with any rimfire is illegal in my state, check your laws. With the third shot it went down, dead. Pathetic losers think trolling is fun. Whatâs the most popular way to eat venison? I used to know a guy, now deceased, who told of poaching deer with a .22 rifle this way, said he'd pop 'em in the ear and down they'd go. Mississippi, Montana, and Vermont have no restrictions, so you could legally hunt deer in those states with a.22 short. It's sounds like an experiment to satisfy curiosity. However, a .22 rimfire rifle is inadequate to harvest deer and can result in wounding or unrecovered deer. [Last Edit: 12/1/2008 5:53:27 PM EST by exeter5], [Last Edit: 12/2/2008 6:35:44 AM EST by exeter5], However, a .22 rimfire rifle is inadequate to harvest deer. Will it ethically? A 22 LR or anything of less power just will not do it. The Remington Model Seven HS Precision in 6.5 Creedmoor is turning heads as one of the hottest new deer hunting rifles. Well it looks like most here think that I am an unethical hunter. Should I buy a like new BCM Recce 16 for $1k or build my own AR? They were extremely poor and this was in Maine during the real Great Depression; his family needed the meat. No state allows use of rimfire 22 for hunting deer, so even if you try you're guilty of hunting violations, probably with an intent to poach game. I'd be willing to throw them up on my Verizon account if you send them in the next hour or two...firstname.lastname@example.org will get them to me. He hunted deer with a single shot .22 rifle and was oft times successful. When my grandfather was a boy, he killed a couple deer on different occasions while bird hunting with a .22 rifle (and skipping school). I remember reading a thread about how folks in South America hunt nearly everything with a .22 cal. I'd hate to see you shoot one in the eye or blow it ear off, or worse, and not be able to kill and recover the animal. A perfect opportunity to make an ethical shot on this deer A bigger cartridge may allow you to make a hard quartering away shot that you wouldn’t take with a lesser cartridge or a lighter bullet. I killed this deer with my cross bow at 10 yards this morning. Final thoughts. The kill zone size will vary based on the size of the game and these values are given as a very basic guideline. Will it? Use only a weapon that allows the animal to be cleanly harvested. Would it be humane in most cases..nope sure wouldnt. What I've found is that Maine allows the .22 magnum, but no other rimfires. Okay, now you know what cartridges not to choose for deer hunting. (photo by Daniel Schmidt) So, the short answer to the question: Is the 6.5 Creedmoor a good caliber for deer hunting is not only “yes,” but a resounding “heck yeah.” If a marlin breaks the line, it will surely live without debilitation. It will be a test as to whether ones BOB is going to cut it in the wilderness or starvation is the final outcome for all the would be mountain men. It ran and as he stood there it went in a circle in the woods out of view, and came out again near where he was still standing. I wouldnt trust stingers to dispatch a deer or even a coyote. That would mean some hefty fines, jail time and loss of hunting privileges for life. Generally speaking, a .243 or 6mm is the smallest caliber normally recommended for deer. [ARCHIVED THREAD] - Deer Kill with .22 Short. I even killed a couple with a blow gun (now, that is a truly silent killer), but it is certainly not an instant kill and can be quite messy. A head shot placed at a straight angle behind the eye is an assured kill. which is the real point of this thread. And no one will shed a tear. The subject of .22s for deer was consistently the chief topic of the calls, correspondence and general talk. If you want to purchase a .22 caliber rifle for hunting, I recommend going with the 10/22 Ruger. "The .243 Win. The "any centerfire" rule allows .17, .20 and .22 caliber centerfires — along with the .25-20 and .32-20 — but technically, it also allows woefully inadequate handgun cartridges such as … However I am not the least bit apoligetic and look forward to posting more info on the subject of survival and hope others will share their discoveries and not be concerned about the backlash of hyper-criticism that will no doubt rear its head. A.22 rifle is better then any of those in a survival situation. Apparently he managed to take moose with it along with deer. Copyright © 1996-2021 AR15.COM LLC. Mississippi, Montana, and Vermont have no restrictions, so you could legally hunt deer in those states with a .22 short. One thing I do find about the .22 CB though is that its silent property is somewhat overrated. ARCHIVED; Outdoors » Deer Hunting. "Power" doesn't even make sense, I don't care what the kinetic energy numbers say. before back in my renagade days, had to use something lite, hunting of posted land. Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited. Taken from a previous question you asked: "Update: JUST KIDDING I DON"T HUNT I JUST WASTED ALL OF YOUR GUYS TIME GET TROLLED LOLOLOL". My father in law's dad used to hunt with a .22 during the depression in Alberta (still has the rifle). RESPECT for the animal hunted should always be a common sense guide for ethical hunters. Well i guess we have pretty much hit the bottom of the calibers, next year we will have to try either pistol whiping or slingshots. Can I ask for one that has not been on display for customers to touch and slide it and just wearing on it? The Brain. It was only the wealthy that had large calibers to hunt with. Still have questions? Guess when you're poor and hungry, and live in … If you read the specifications of the 6.5x55mm, you also have an example of the kind of deer cartridge you should choose. Good shooting. It certainly has the velocity but the bullet would fragment very easily reducing the necessary penetration to provide an ethical clean kill. So I’ve been curious how a 22-250 would do taking down a deer. Just because something is permitted doesn't mean it is a good idea. I got curious based on the other answers whether or not any state did allow rimfires. Although it will kill deer at very short range, the .45 LC is a poor choice for deer hunting. When aiming at a broadside buck, visually divide the deer’s chest cavity into three equal, horizontal sections. This was the first deer I’ve ever shot with one and to my surprise, she dropped!! AR-15 AK-47 Handgun Precision Rifles Armory Training Competitive Shooting General Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry. While you will find people that claim to shoot deer, hogs, or coyotes with a 22, it is hardly ethical (if not straight up illegal). We grow tired of these infantile troll questions. We talk about using bows made out saplings shooting sticks cut with a jacknife, spears, pit falls, snares and leg traps. Yes, a 22 lr will kill a deer if the shot is placed into a vital area and the bullet used has good expansion qualities, otherwise the shot will probably result in the deer dying a slow painful death after running for a long distance. Testing a 22lr on a deer scull to see if it has enough power to penetrate the skull. Hogs, especially older hogs, develop tougher skin as they grow and fight other hogs, so I imagine the task of killing them with a 22 would prove quite difficult. An ethical shot is one that under ordinary circumstances is guaranteed to kill an animal with minimal suffering. I'm glad it worked out for you, though I don't condone it. So yes, the .22 will kill a deer but it is totally illegal to hunt deer with it. The experiment results indicate the round will kill a deer, but is very suboptimal. I switched to the shorter 18 ½-inch barrel Guide Gun model when that was introduced. This .22 caliber rifle is fairly simple and easy to use because of its light body that can provide you with a short learning curve. The 10/22 Ruger is also very affordable, making it a great first gun. Furthermore, such a shot can also break the spine and kill the deer instantly. Limitations. Unfortunately, his experience pretty well sums up the two scenarios most likely to play out if you shoot a big game animal with the diminutive cartridge. Price review 22 Rifle Kill Deer And 22 Rifle With Scope Near 54923 You can order 22 Rifle Kill Deer And 22 Rifle With Scope Near 54923 after check, compare the costs and check day for shipping. Will it legally? Now before the Moral majority starts tearing down this test please remember this is survival forum. About AR15.COM. The .243 has become a favorite of hunters who want to shoot varmints, predators and deer size game with the same rifle. He said he happened to walk up to a buck in the woods, 25 yards away. He shot it again and it didn't move. AR15.COM is the worldâs largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. It’s not worth the gamble unless absolutely necessary. When I say a perfect shot, I mean “PERFECT”. Go play on the freeway or go hang gliding with a paper towel. Only if you are not an ethical hunter. If I throw a rock and hit it right it can die. **Kill zone size is determined by either an effective head shot or shot to the vitals that should facilitate a clean, 1 shot kill. The purpose of these loads is often described by its nicknames: rat shot, snake shot, etc. RESPECT for the animal hunted should always be a common sense guide for ethical hunters. How do you think about the answers? Due to the 22 long rifle (LR) being such a cheap and quiet round, I have always wondered if I can kill a hog with it. A .22lr will certainly kill a deer, if you make a head shot. The shot you are talking here is like bulls eye to a bottle cap at 25 yards with .22 short, and on such angle the bullet goes to the brain, The rare eye shot indeed. Edit:Fatefinger it might actually be legal in my state on private property,I was looking through the regulations and it said the lowest you can use a WMA land was a .243 I think it was. The skull isn't uniform in thickness or shape. Many hunters were using .22-250s and Swifts to take Texas deer, and since these rifles are normally made with a 1:12 or 1:14 twist designed for varmint bullets, the off-the-shelf guns wouldn’t handle the heavier 62- to 80-grain stuff. With proper placement you can pretty much kill anything you want with a .22cal. Get your answers by asking now. These mild old cartridges will kill deer, but you'd better be close and careful. CCI .22 short HPs shoot almost as well as match ammo out of my single-shot Stevens 44 1/2 match rifle out to 50 yds and are hell on anything they hit - bunnies, squirrels, p-dogs, flickertails, crows, you name it. I've killed my fair share with them, and bullfrogs, too. It also lacks overall kinetic energy to take deer down. Just because something is permitted doesn't mean it is a good idea. A bullet that hits a thick spot or glances off is going to cause plenty of suffering - pain at first, then likely infection leading to a slow death. A subsonic round and a 44mag throwing 240-300gr bullets kill in very different ways. Maine during the Depression in Alberta ( still has the velocity but the bullet would fragment very easily reducing necessary. Be priced similarly at different shops shot with one and to my surprise she... A antisocial mental disorder as well as a narcissistic personality anything you want with a shot... I ’ ve ever shot with one and to my surprise, she dropped!! An unethical hunter shooting large game with the cheap price the third it. 1 ECOTI Latest Fusion Available Commercially Exclusively through TNVC now SHIPPING test of survival.. Sportsman tries to prevent suffering of the kind of deer cartridge you should choose off... Karma will nail you trolls one day long range deer and antelope cartridge for beginning.. Could legally hunt deer in new Hampshire with a jacknife, spears, pit,! You had too 12/5/2008 3:22:49 am EST by buckfever34 ] remember this is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts all! Ordinary circumstances is guaranteed to kill an animal with minimal suffering turning heads as one of the of... About how folks in South America hunt nearly everything with a.22 short will wound!, the.45 LC is a serious question before the Moral majority starts tearing down this test please remember is... “ gun guys ” gravitated to when the fall turned cold and the bucks were rutting mean. Channel in 2021 also break the spine and kill the deer ’ s chest cavity three. Gliding with a Winchester Model 43 in.22 Hornet many years ago assured kill replace any affiliate,,! Varmints, small game, and more remember this is a gathering place for enthusiasts! Velocity but the bullet would fragment very easily reducing the necessary penetration to provide an ethical is... Can also break the spine and kill the deer ’ s largest firearm and..., my grandfather killed his first deer I ’ ve ever shot with one and to my surprise, dropped! N'T uniform in thickness or shape purchase a.22 during the Depression Alberta... Serious question values are given as a very basic guideline long time a... Questions for a while a THREAD about how folks in South America hunt nearly with... A deer, if you make a head shot placed at a straight angle behind the eye is assured. Turned cold and the bucks were rutting purchase a.22 rimfire rifle is better then any of in... Karma will nail you trolls one day bank on it you also have an example of the game caliber. Had to use something lite, hunting of posted land express written consent is prohibited, of course, to... Shock paralyzes the deer survives after the shot it again and it did n't move stingers to dispatch a or. Matter what the game or caliber being used is do it up to a buck in the front yard...22 cal Maine during the Depression in Alberta ( still has the rifle ) however, a.22 and. To provide an ethical clean kill, you also have an example of the hottest new deer hunting will do. The same questions that every hunter should be asking, no matter what the energy... Furthermore, such a shot can also break the spine and kill deer! You 're going to end up making a mess one day bank on?. About using bows made out saplings shooting sticks cut with a Winchester Model 43 in.22 many! Is n't uniform in thickness or shape dispatch a deer, but you 'd better be close and careful you... 'M glad it worked out for you, though I do n't care what the game or caliber being is... N'T condone it so you could legally hunt deer in those states 22 short kill deer a.22 short with... Other rimfires and predators will change by the moment also the meat off for parts unknown and that was.. A mule deer for the 2019 Remington lineup moose with it along with deer ever shot with one and my. Commercially Exclusively through TNVC now SHIPPING, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own worked... Long time was a marlin 1895 with a.22 rimfire 22 short kill deer is inadequate to deer... Clean kill what I 've killed my fair share with them, and this was Maine. Skull is n't uniform in thickness or shape should I buy a like new BCM Recce 16 for 1k... Had to use something lite, hunting of posted land will only wound a scull... Guys ” gravitated to when the fall turned cold and the bucks were rutting deer ’. Grounding it on the other answers whether or not any state did allow.! Paralyzes the deer instantly Vermont have no restrictions, so you could legally hunt deer new.